25/09/2007
EU directive to limit use of MRI in cancer treatment
Source: AFP
Cancer researchers warned at a ECCO conference in Barcelona, Spain, on 24 September 2007 that an EU directive on limiting magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) could halt use of an important tool in the fight against the disease.
The directive is set to be implemented across Europe by April next year and was drawn up to limit medical workers' exposure to electromagnetic fields.
But Professor Dag Rune Olsen, a specialist in experimental radiation therapy at the Norwegian Radiation Hospital in Oslo, told the European Cancer Conference that the directive could put at risk some eight million annual MRI scans, hampering patient treatment.
"These are likely to have to stop, since the directive sets limits to occupational radiation exposure which will mean that anyone working or moving near MRI equipment will breach them, thus making it possible for them to sue their employers," he said.
"Even those maintaining or servicing the equipment may be affected," said Olsen, who is also chairman of the physics committee of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology (ESTRO).
Britain's Health and Safety Executive published a study in June 2007, undertaken by Professor Stuart Crozier of Brisbane University, Australia, which found that anyone standing within about one metre (yard) of an MRI scanner in use would breach the exposure limits laid down in the EU directive.
EU authorities are now considering amendments to the directive.
According to Professor Olsen, "Slovakia has already implemented the directive, on the grounds that it was based on the assumption that the limits which it sets would have no effect. This would appear to mean that it is now illegal to carry out MRI scanning in the country."
In a statement, conference organisers said the directive "will also stop the use of MRI for interventional and surgical procedures, and will curtail cutting edge research."
"The added value that MRI represents to medical diagnostics has been tremendous," Olsen insisted.
He said he hoped there could be a delay in the directive's implementation, while also warning against "hasty decisions without scientific support".
Professor John Smyth, president of the Federation of European Cancer Societies (FECS), meanwhile warned that political decisions were harming cancer treatment in Europe.
He cited the MRI directive as an example and said that "(it) looks as though it may stop all MRI scanning in Europe".
The directive is set to be implemented across Europe by April next year and was drawn up to limit medical workers' exposure to electromagnetic fields.
But Professor Dag Rune Olsen, a specialist in experimental radiation therapy at the Norwegian Radiation Hospital in Oslo, told the European Cancer Conference that the directive could put at risk some eight million annual MRI scans, hampering patient treatment.
"These are likely to have to stop, since the directive sets limits to occupational radiation exposure which will mean that anyone working or moving near MRI equipment will breach them, thus making it possible for them to sue their employers," he said.
"Even those maintaining or servicing the equipment may be affected," said Olsen, who is also chairman of the physics committee of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology (ESTRO).
Britain's Health and Safety Executive published a study in June 2007, undertaken by Professor Stuart Crozier of Brisbane University, Australia, which found that anyone standing within about one metre (yard) of an MRI scanner in use would breach the exposure limits laid down in the EU directive.
EU authorities are now considering amendments to the directive.
According to Professor Olsen, "Slovakia has already implemented the directive, on the grounds that it was based on the assumption that the limits which it sets would have no effect. This would appear to mean that it is now illegal to carry out MRI scanning in the country."
In a statement, conference organisers said the directive "will also stop the use of MRI for interventional and surgical procedures, and will curtail cutting edge research."
"The added value that MRI represents to medical diagnostics has been tremendous," Olsen insisted.
He said he hoped there could be a delay in the directive's implementation, while also warning against "hasty decisions without scientific support".
Professor John Smyth, president of the Federation of European Cancer Societies (FECS), meanwhile warned that political decisions were harming cancer treatment in Europe.
He cited the MRI directive as an example and said that "(it) looks as though it may stop all MRI scanning in Europe".
Latest publications
Vienna seminar and symposium presentations
You may now view your favorite presentations from the 16th Congress of the EAHP as the audio and video presentations are now available online. To view, please click on the dvd above. You may also order the cd/dvd by emailing sec (@) eahp.eu.